Best Restaurants in Manteo and Roanoke Island: A Foodie's Guide to Outer Banks Dining
Manteo, one of North Carolina's oldest towns, serves as the charming "capital" of Roanoke Island in the Outer Banks. With white picket fences, boutique shops, and inviting restaurants, it's a destination that captures hearts instantly, evoking simpler times and rich history—including the enduring mystery of The Lost Colony. Manteo and Roanoke Island offer an ideal fall escape with pristine beaches, stunning sunsets, historical landmarks, and exceptional cuisine.
For food enthusiasts, this area delivers a diverse array of dining options. Expect the freshest seafood from local waters, alongside sandwiches, burgers, and upscale fare to suit every palate and budget. We've curated our top picks—let's explore them.
Tuna sashimi from Blue Water Grill
Blue Water Grill in Manteo
Blue Water Grill
Start at Blue Water Grill in Manteo, renowned for wild-caught fish and locally farmed oysters. Dine with breathtaking waterfront views at sunset or relax at the bar with sports on multiple TVs. Don't miss the tiki hut at Pirate's Cove Marina, offering the full menu in a laid-back setting with live entertainment. It's the perfect spot to immerse yourself in the Outer Banks vibe.
Take a seat in the 1587 Lounge
Craft cocktails from the 1587 Lounge
1587 Lounge
At the Tranquil House Inn on Manteo's waterfront, this new lounge offers local microbrews, small plates, a full bar, and an excellent wine list. Its breezy living room atmosphere, comfy seating, cocktails, and water views make it an ideal end to a day of exploration. Stay in one of the uniquely decorated rooms at this iconic Nantucket-style inn for the full experience.
The famous fish tacos at The Avenue Grille
The Avenue Waterfront Grille
Overlooking Shallowbag Bay and Manteo harbor, this grille specializes in local seafood, steaks, and burgers. They creatively accommodate dietary needs with vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options. Standouts include Tuna Sushi Style, Fish Tacos, Shrimp and Grits, and inventive burgers. Enjoy complimentary spectacular views.
Welcome to Ortega'z
Ortega'z Southwest Grill and Wine Bar
Featured on Food Network's Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives with Guy Fieri, Ortega'z blends Southwest flavors with Outer Banks ingredients. Its welcoming vibe draws locals and visitors alike. Expect great food, hospitality, and drinks in a relaxed setting.
A dockside sandwich at Poor Richard's Sandwich Shop
Poor Richard's Sandwich Shop
An Outer Banks icon for over 35 years, this pub-deli is famous for its Reuben, served with a dill pickle and views of Shallowbag Bay and Manteo Marina.
The Hungry Pelican in Downtown Manteo
The Hungry Pelican
A downtown Manteo staple since 2002 with 30+ years of roots, owners claim over 500,000 sandwiches made. Choose from 25+ options, plus fresh house-made salads and soups.
The fish market at O'Neals Sea Harvest
O'Neals Sea Harvest
In Wanchese fishing village, this spot embodies Outer Banks seafood. Lunch on the fried soft crab BLT, then shop their market for the freshest catch, direct from local waters.
Welcome to El Shaddai Chicken
El Shaddai Chicken
This roadside diner shines with authentic Peruvian dishes like citrus-marinated ceviche, lomo saltado, arroz chaufa, and jalea mixta, featuring local seafood.
Grab a beer - or 9 - at the Lost Colony Brewery and Café
Lost Colony Brewery and Café
Sample award-winning ales, stouts, blondes, and IPAs at their taproom, paired with comforting pub fare. A local favorite featured in national media, available across 50+ OBX spots.
Conveniently, most spots are walkable in Manteo's downtown waterfront—park once and savor Outer Banks flavors on foot.
